V Stage - Top 10 acts

United Kingdom | by Greg Rose | 21 August 2007

And while some of the more 'rock'n'roll' acts are spread out over the peripheral stages, all eyes are on the main V Stage. We know all the bands here can sell records, but who will claim V Festival 2007 as their own?

We gave Greg Rose a mac and never ending lager, nailed him into the mud and asked him to find out...

10. Goo Goo Dolls – Sunday, 1.25pm – 1.05pm.

Being past it is problematic, especially when you weren’t particularly great in your prime. However, Goo Goo Dolls don’t let this bother them as they entertain a swelling afternoon crowd with their meandering brand of inauthentic rock. They couldn’t look less cool if they daubed their heads in red bandanas and dyed their greying hair. Hang on – the bass player’s wearing a red bandana, while singer John Rzeznik has definitely been at the Just For Men.

But then, when you have a barnstorming, inexplicably epic anthem like 'Iris' in your arsenal nothing else really matters. Despite the rest of the set sounding like budget Bon Jovi, 'Iris' transforms the lethargic audience into a huge, cheesy choir, screaming back the words with gusto and glee.  In three minutes of infectious 80s stadium rock, Goo Goo Dolls become the perfect hangover tonic.

9. The Fratellis – Sunday, 4.50pm – 5.40pm.

Playing to one of the largest crowds of the weekend, the Scottish scallywags deliver what the punters want: scuzzy, gutter-dwelling geezer indie. The seemingly endless stream of big hooks and gibberish lyrics is gobbled up hungrily by the baying fans. While 'Henrietta' is merrily disorderly, 'Creeping Up The Backstairs' is riotous. While 'Dog In A Bag' is a bawling brawl, 'Nuts From A Hippy' is a bass-fuelled frenzy. Their amps are dubbed with the question “Nae Danger?” Well, there is nae danger of a song without a chugging riff and a shouted chorus.

Nevertheless, although all variety and subtlety are lost, the barrage of noise appeases the jumping crowd as it readies itself for the finale. When it arrives, riding on a tide of testosterone, 'Chelsea Dagger' is the crown prince of bloke anthems. The band play it at double-time, moving the crowd from rowdy to rapturous and leaving even the most cynical doubter admitting The Fratellis know how to rouse a rabble.

8. KT Tunstall - Sunday, 3.35pm – 4.20pm

Dressed completely in angelic white but sporting a punky streak of blond in her flowing mane of hair, KT Tunstall aims to bridge the often unbridgeable gap between commercial success and credibility. Blessed only with a hoarse, unremarkable voice, she pulls through on guts and hard work. Every stomp of her foot, wail of her accent and strum of her guitar seems an effort. But all this labouring produces a pleasant, likeable sound.

It is inexplicably pop, but is also scented with heartfelt, folky lyrics. 'The Other Side of the World' bubbles with longing as KT delivers an earnest performance. Set-closer 'Suddenly I See' is received most warmly; she does this brand of hand-waving sing-along fodder better than most. However, there is a resolute determination to her performance that raises it above the merely enjoyable, into the realms of the credibility she clearly craves.

7. Paolo Nutini - Saturday, 3:35pm – 4.40pm.

The only thing in more plentiful supply than average singer-songwriters this weekend is drizzle. Happily, Paolo Nutini is sufficiently superior to most of his soppy peers to make standing in said drizzle worthwhile. Although middle-aged women stand impatiently screaming “Play Jenny!” throughout, he resists the temptation to become a bland crowd-pleaser.

Unafraid to rattle into extended jams, he even spirals into a comical “I wanna be like you-ooh-ooh” ode to The Jungle Book. When he does play a ragged version of 'Jenny Don’t Be Hasty', it is a rollicking treat that is closer to Bruce Springsteen than James Blunt. Looking stylishly wasted, Nutini has grit and attitude to compliment his numerous chart-bothering, housewife anthems.

6. Kasabian - Sunday, 7.40pm – 8.40pm.

Having headlined the second stage last year, Kasabian found themselves shunted sideways to play penultimately on the main stage this time around. Opening with the electrifying groove of 'Shoot The Runner', they play with a fearsome intent that suggests they deserve a desired headlining slot sooner rather than later. Guitarist Serge is all verve and grace, while singer Tom stalks the stage with a rabid, infectious energy.

The band releases the same feelings of fervent masculinity as The Fratellis, but everything seems multiplied in scale. The hooks are huger, beats meatier and vocals more snarling. 'Processed Beats' reverberates inside the chests of the sweaty hordes as Tom triumphantly knights them, bellowing “you lot are Empire.” There is even time to showcase a more delicate side on 'Me Plus One', before the festival-slaying refrain of 'L.S.F' confirms Kasabian as Britain’s premier lad-rockers.

5. Rodrigo Y Gabriela - Sunday, 12.30pm – 1.00pm.

This Mexican duo doesn’t use flashy stage sets and gimmicks. Or drums. Or bass. Or even vocals. Relying purely on their ability to play guitars in a rapid, sunshine-tinged manner, they hold onlookers spellbound. With cameras stuck onto their instruments to allow the audience to glimpse their extraordinary musical prowess, Rodrigo Y Gabriela open the V Stage on Sunday with a delightful set of Latin-laced, toe-tapping numbers.

A cover of Pink Floyd’s 'Wish You Were Here' sees many of the crowd fill in the words as Rodrigo encourages the nodding heads to join in. There is a curiously contained atmosphere, possibly explained by the peculiarity of festival-goers witnessing such original music gracing the same stage James Morrison would soon be playing on. But the quality of the finger picking – at one stage becoming so intense Gabriela’s strings break – and improvising is undoubted. Different and exhilarating, Rodrigo Y Gabriela are a surprising pleasure.

4. Editors - Saturday, 2.30pm – 3.10pm.

Having been handed an afternoon set-time, thankfully the weather holds out long enough for Editors to play in suitable conditions. This means the expected sun doesn’t arrive; instead the band’s uncompromisingly atmospheric rock is allowed to flourish in a fittingly overcast gloom.

Tom Smith’s gothic, almost operatic vocals dominate over soaring riffs that agitate the feet and stir the brain. As 'All Sparks' sizzles past, replaced by the blistering attack on the senses that is 'Bullets', you realise Editors have secretly amassed a back catalogue of brooding hits capable of altering an indifferent gathering into a swaying mass. Their spiky rhythms and haunting melodies conjure images of Joy Division sound-tracking a Dracula film. Who knew afternoon sets at V could be so darkly engaging?

3. Foo Fighters - Saturday, 9.20pm – 10.50pm

Dave Grohl surveys the crowd like prey, a crazed tribe leader with a hungry, maniacal glint in his eye. He had cajoled fans over to the V Stage (away from The Kooks, headlining elsewhere) by serenading them with a secret acoustic set earlier on. Now, he makes his intentions clear. Touching opener 'Everlong' is quickly dispatched as the high-octane rock marathon begins. 'Breakout', 'Monkey Wrench' and a brutal rendition of 'Stacked Actors' all fly by in a blur of scorching guitars.

Soon, Dave finds time to banter with the crowd, giving a nod to “a band I used to play drums in….” No, not Nirvana – Juliette and the Licks. In these moments, he steers Foo Fighters with trepidation between seriousness and slapstick, unsure whether to remain menacing or mischievous. 'Best of You'’s dangerously gruff roar restores the tone as the satisfied crowd repeat its refrain; finally, the band blast through closing number 'All My Life'. They can roll out festival-pleasing sets like this with ease, but the intensity they achieve marks every one as memorable.

2. The Killers - Sunday, 9.20pm – 10.50pm.

A British festival this summer just wouldn’t feel complete without Las Vegas’ finest bringing a dose of powerful glitz to the proceedings. So it is no surprise that this festival-ending set is a set to end all festivals. For a crowd that demands more hits from its artists than Pete Doherty does from his dealer, The Killers are ideal. Every single song seems cosily familiar as the band manufactures a togetherness that includes the whole audience. Brandon pouts and poses, guitars and jackets shimmer, the jumping throng below them laps it up.

'Somebody Told Me' is expertly executed and a clear highlight, its bass line whirling over expectant faces. Numerous tracks from latest album Sam’s Town keep the atmosphere frenetic. 'Bones' sexily combines glam with danger; 'Read My Mind' confidently pacifies those hoping for a dash of sensitivity amongst all the hedonism. Then it's left to the heavyweight combination of universal favourites 'Mr. Brightside' and 'All These Things I’ve Done' to complete the festival. While the former makes a nearby girl cry, the latter prompts every attendee to cry out joyfully and sing along; this was a masterclass of rock showmanship.

1. Kanye West - Saturday, 4.50pm – 5.40pm.

The fact a rapper can represent the spirit of a festival in such all-encompassing terms speaks much of V Festival’s nature. Including a greater range of ages, outlooks and styles can lead to a more saturated, somehow diluted weekend. But in Kanye West’s genre-ripping, convention-defying set, the principles of V come together seamlessly. With eager fans donning his trademark slit sunglasses he blitzes the stage with current number one single 'Stronger'. Merging his signature cheek with the brash sound of Daft Punk, it signals for a sample-heavy set combining energy with wit.

Amy Winehouse, The Verve and Timbaland all receive the West reworking treatment as his disjointed but enthralling show continues. On 'Through The Wire', he sings less “about coke and birds, more like spoken word.” His reluctance to purely rely on rap clichés, instead embracing music rich history, moves Kanye from average to astounding. He races exuberantly across stage while his string section delivers 'Touch The Sky'. Fans here for MOR acts join with indie scenesters in reacting to the infectious American, the brilliance of the 50-minutes, mirroring V itself, lying in its diversity, its inclusiveness and, ultimately, its sense of fun.

One who should have stayed at home: Pink - Saturday, 6.10pm – 7.10pm

Pink is the scariest woman I have ever seen. Scowling and grunting, she owns thighs capable of crushing every indie twiglet in attendance like a particularly irksome insect. This alone doesn’t lower her further than the soppiness of James Morrison, or Snow Patrol’s bland soullessness. It doesn’t even induce wretching like Just Jack’s corny Mike Skinner impression does.

What makes Pink the weekend’s stinker is her self-appointed status as preacher to the masses. Whenever a singer states they are going to get serious, it’s a cue to run. When Pink says “I wanna get political with y’all,” it’s a cue to chop your ears off with the nearest blunt object. After playing the mundane drawl of Dear Mr President it’s unlikely Mr. Bush will be seriously considering major policy changes. The accompanying images of dead soldiers and crying children don’t exactly ignite the festival spirit, so it’s back to plastic punk.

There is time for a cover of 'What’s Goin’ On', which convinces middle-aged flower pop fans to attempt hitting notes higher than their IQs. Finally, 'Get The Party Started' is mutilated by a combination of Pink’s voice – too wavering to be punk, too barking to be diva-like – and Brian May’s evil twin plodding out an excruciating electric guitar solo continuously. This butchering of music may be fine for teeny-bopper-filled arenas. But please keep it out of our festivals.